Best Mexican in Newcastle: the tacos and margaritas locals rate
Where to go for tacos and margaritas in Newcastle, from a quick bite to a sit-down dinner worth booking, chosen from what locals say in their Google reviews.
By the Made in Newy deskChecked 14 October 20265 independents, no chains
Quick answer: fish tacos at Antojitos Taqueria in Newcastle West, cocktails at Papalote on Parry Street, and margaritas at Mucho's in The Junction. Each group runs from the most Google reviews down.
Antojitos Taqueria in Newcastle West has the most Google reviews of any Mexican place in the city, and fish tacos come up in more of them than any other dish. Papalote Mexican on Parry Street has the highest Google rating of the places in this guide.
Where can I get tacos in Newcastle?
Antojitos has taquerias on Steel Street, Newcastle West, and Maitland Road, Mayfield. Beaches Cantina on Darby Street runs Taco Tuesday.
Where can I get a margarita in Newcastle?
Margaritas are the thing reviewers mention most at Mucho's Mexican in The Junction, and cocktails lead the reviews at Beaches Cantina and Papalote.
How we made this guide
We started from the places that come up in Google Maps searches for Mexican food and tacos in Newcastle, left out the chains, and read each one's Google listing and up to its latest 300 Google reviews on 14 October 2026. Ratings and hours change, so check before you go. We have not been paid by anyone in this guide. If something has changed, tell us.