Eight independent pizza places across Newcastle, from wood-fired restaurants to takeaway favourites, with the pizzas locals order most and what to know before you go.
By the Made in Newy deskChecked 14 October 20268 independents, no chains
Quick answer: wood-fired at Napoli Centrale on King Street, thin and crispy at DiRoma in Merewether, and gluten-free bases at Best Coast Pizza. Each group runs from the most Google reviews down.
Wood-fired pizza worth booking a table for
Neapolitan bases, a glass of wine, and a seat near the oven.
10 of the latest 300 Google reviews mention the pork belly pizza
A traditional Italian restaurant on Hunter Street West with wood-fired pizza, pasta and pizza-making classes.
What locals say
"An amazing wood fired pizza restaurant that ticked all the boxes"
Five-star Google review
"Absolutely incredible food & great service. We had the meatballs as an entree and shared a pasta & pizza for the main. Will be back to try more meals!!"
Five-star Google review
What locals order most
Vegan options41 reviews
Arancini15 reviews
Marinara12 reviews
Address
545 Hunter St, Newcastle West
Hours
Mon to Thu 11.30am to 2.30pm5pm to 8.30pmFri and Sat 11.30am to 2.30pm5pm to 9pmSun 11.30am to 2.30pm5pm to 8pm
An Italian-inspired cafe and aperitivo bar in Tighes Hill with wood-fired pizza, vintage decor and dogs welcome.
What locals say
"always delicious! came back quite a few times now, always get the pizza and it’s consistently yummy! would recommend to anyone looking for loaded up, woodfire pizzas!"
Five-star Google review
"Lovely hidden gem. Pizza was amazing (something special about the dough). Will be back for sure"
Napoli Centrale on King Street has the most Google reviews of the pizza places in this guide, for wood-fired Neapolitan pizza. For takeaway, I Love Pizza in Hamilton has the highest Google rating.
Where can I get vegan pizza in Newcastle?
Vegan options come up in more reviews of Harry's Gourmet Pizza in Adamstown than anything else. Napoli Centrale and Bella Italia also get mentions for their vegan options.
Where can I get gluten-free pizza in Newcastle?
Best Coast Pizza in Merewether makes its thin crust on an original, wholemeal spelt or gluten-free base.
How we made this guide
We started from the places that come up in Google Maps searches for pizza in Newcastle, left out the chains, and read each one's Google listing and up to its latest 300 Google reviews on 14 October 2026. Ratings and hours change, so check before you go. We have not been paid by anyone in this guide. If something has changed, tell us.